Fatherly Stuff: Pink: How a Color Taught me a Priceless Lesson about Gender Bias and Fatherhood

May 9, 2019

Pink: How a Color Taught me a Priceless Lesson about Gender Bias and Fatherhood

This is a republished post. 

I’ve always considered myself a pretty progressive dad, riding the wave of modernity in the 21st century. In our household, the lines of the past that steadfastly identified what was considered “man” and “woman” responsibilities were more opaque and everything from diaper changing, feeding, paying bills and getting up late at night to tend to a sleeping baby is divided based on whoever’s hand is on deck at any given time. It’s not the easiest job in the world, but to be honest I felt pretty good about being what most people would label a “modern dad” and I wore that title like a badge of honor.

My title was put to the test however the day my wife brought this home for my son:



The first thing I said to my wife was: “Um that can’t be for my son. That thing is wearing a skirt”
“So?”
“Well, skirts are for girls, and he’s a boy so we have to return it for a monkey with a pair of jeans or something”

My wife rolls her eyes, calmly asserts that I am being silly and eventually the toy is given to my son. That little hula monkey ends up being one of his favorite toys as an infant and I realized that I indeed was making a big deal out of nothing.

Fast forward to his toddler stage:
My son is asked what his favorite color was and he emphatically replies that it is pink. Deep down his answer made me a bit uncomfortable, but I didn't show it: I gave him a hug and told let him know how awesome his selection was.
 But why did I have that reaction? What hell was I afraid of?
Well for starters, pink is a girl color. It’s not just “a” girl color, but the international spokescolor (yes, a made up word) for the female gender. You see it on every dress, tutu and Barbie convertible that is marketed towards little girls. So how could it be that my son, who loves to collect bugs, do karate and play with race cars would actually like something that is so obviously... "girly"? When I was a kid, if you we're a boy who admitted you were a fan of pink, you’d instantly be labeled a sissy and be the object of ridicule of every bully in a three classroom radius. I suppose my fear stemmed from a misguided desire to protect him from that kind of scrutiny. (I also believe that it is more frowned upon for little boys to explore activities outside the perceived gender role, than it is for girls to do the same. But this is subject matter for another post!)
After some reflection however, I began to understand that the issue was not with him liking this color, but with the fact that I had a problem with it at all. I then realized that maybe I’m not as much of a forward-thinking father as I had thought. Maybe I'm just as guilty of the same male chauvinistic stereotypes that were the norm during my father’s generation and the generation before his.
After I accepted this reality, I then decided to explore these feelings in order to understand, then overcome them.

And so began my journey...
So, who decided that pink was a “girl” color anyway? After doing a little research, it turns out that the practice of associating colors with gender is a fairly recent concept.
Photo Credit
  

When you look at the above picture, what do you see?

If you said girl, you would be wrong. Not only is this frilly young lad a boy, he is none other than Franklin D Roosevelt, one of the greatest US presidents who ever lived.  This picture, which was taken in 1884 is a reflection of the views of that time period. It was actually a normal practice for parents to have both boys and girls wear gender-neutral white dresses throughout their early childhood. By age 7, boys would finally start wearing pants and would get their first haircut. If I had to guess, I would suspect that this was done as more of a cost saving measure by the parents.
 According to an article posted on the Smithsonian Magazine’swebsite, there was a time as early as 1918 when pink was considered the primary color for boys and blue for girls. The public perception began to change around the time accurate prenatal testing had become standard practice. Child and infant clothing retailers, looking to make money, capitalized on this trend began to shift their products and advertising campaigns toward gender specific colors.
Then the cycle is perpetuated: as these gender specific colors become more defined, as parents and as a society, we tend to push these values onto our children and an earlier and earlier. I’m almost certain that my perceptions were directly influenced based on this trend.

So basically, the wool was systematically pulled over my eyes to believe the pink is a color exclusively for the female sex from the moment I arrived on this earth.

Despite this however, there's already evidence of the tide beginning to change.
Photo Credit
This picture of a mother and son with pink panted toenails, was taken for the 2011 J. Crew spring catalog and caused quite the controversy, but it is also an indicator that the mainstream is once again evolving and pushing boundaries.

For me, the picture didn't bother me at all. I figured, whatever that little boy's parents choose to do with their child is their business. Little did I know that my son would once again unknowingly push my personal boundaries.

I came home from a long day's work to a giggling wife. Perplexed, I asked her what was up. She sheepishly opens up her phone and shows me this picture:



Apparently, he saw mommy painting her nails and thought it would be cool to do copy her. He then grabbed his marker and proceeded to color his toes. My wife thought it was hilarious. I'm ashamed to say that I blew it out of proportion and was pretty upset. I considered scolding him or at least explaining why what he did was wrong. Thankfully my wife brought me back down to earth, just like with the hula monkey situation and reminded me that I was being ridiculous. He was only a toddler and if I did end up confronting him with negative reinforcement, it would have likely done more harm than good. It has been about a year since that ordeal; he has never brought it up nor attempted to do such a thing again.

So going through all of this, what lessons have i learned?

 I've learned by understanding the false stereotypes that were taught to me in my youth, I am able accept the past without compromising my future. All that matters is the fact that I love my son and as his father, it is my job to ensue he is raised in an environment where he feel safe to express himself. And that includes him deciding to like pink, purple, blue or any other color he so wishes. Or if he ever wanted to try on his mommy's shoes. Or any other thing that someone might consider "girly". I will almost bet you that in the eyes of a child, most activities that we as adults tend to categorize with a gender are completely neutral to them.

Plus, who knows? Maybe in 50 years, pink will be the "it" color for boys once again.

Question: Have you ever been confronted with your own gender biases with your child(ren)? How did you react?


14 comments:

  1. Great post, Kyle. At the age of 3, one of my twin boys decided he only wanted to wear black, and we jokingly referred to him as Johnny Cash. Eventually, he grew out of the all-black thing. When they were small, one of their favorite toys was a kitchen set, which might have been perceived as feminine. It sure did keep them busy. Their father is an avid hunter and fisherman, so once they were a little older, weekends were spent camping out in the GA wilderness. They've had a good balance of masculine and feminine influences. We went along with whatever it was they seemed interested at the time, regardless of whether it was traditionally male or female. They've both turned out fine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I totally agree that both little boys and little girls need a balance of both masculine and feminine influences in order to become well rounded individuals. That is the "plan" for my little guy. Thanks for the comment!

      Delete
  2. I, as well, am sure that you son will turn out well, mainly because you're a great father guiding him in the best way you can and in the best way it is possible. Loved the post, will come for more.

    Growing up and even now I'm described as more feminine than masculine (FYI, I am a guy) people apparently have a problem with that, even my own parents, I used to have a problem with that too but I'm growing out of it, let them waste their time pointing fingers at me while I'm enjoying myself just the way I am.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Gabriel for your kind words! Sorry to hear about your struggles, but I guess we all go through some kind of trial at some point in our lives and it sounds like you've found a measure of peace. Glad you've been able to keep moving forward!

      Delete
  3. I really enjoyed this post. The gender lines are teaching kids division at an early age. I am the father to two little girls and everyday i am challenged in this way. They see the things I've done such as the military and other things and i have to tell them the realities in our society. I want them to be ambitious, strong young women and i never say they can't do it, i just tell them it will be a challenge that they can overcome.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's awesome, Tony. Girls certainly do have it rough, but thanks to dads like you empowering their daughters progress is being made. Thanks for commenting and thank you for your service!

      Delete
  4. My daughter loves dolls AND Transformers (specifically Optimus Prime and Bumble Bee) From what I've seen on the playground, I think there are more raised eyebrows when boys play with "girl" toys. So score 1 for your son for having a dad who wants him to be himself...in whatever wonderful color that turns out to be :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great point, Gina. There does seem to be more scrutiny against boys that do something that is "girly" than the other way around. It's funny: in the first draft of this post, I was going to write a little about that, but that subject in itself is so charged, it could be an article all on it's own. So I cut it out, but maybe I'll add a little back in. Anyways, thanks for the kind words and for commenting!

      Delete
  5. Kyle, both your son and wife sound like true free spirits, and it's plain to see you're one yourself. What better atmosphere for a child to grow up in. He'll make up his own mind what's right for him, and convention be damned.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Convention be dammed indeed! Thanks, nothingprofound!

      Delete
  6. I love reading your posts because they usually cause me to self-reflect. (always a good thing!).
    I probably would have reacted initially the same way you did. And then I thought...my husband's favorite color is purple...kind of in that men shouldn't like that girly color stereotype as well. And, I absolutely love when he wears a pink oxford or polo shirt, which he often does when we go to "Wear Pink for Breast Cancer" fund raisers.
    Thanks for a good read, again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great perspective, Bonnie. I also own both pink and purple dress shirts that I regularly wear to work. I probably should change my title to,
      Real men (and boys) are arent afraid to like pink"!

      Delete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete